> ## Content Index
> Fetch the complete content index at: https://spyglass.org/llms.txt
> Use this file to discover other available public pages before exploring further.

# May the 4th, Rank the 4th
- URL: https://spyglass.org/may-the-4th/
- Published: 2024-05-04T22:22:00.000Z
- Updated: 2024-09-02T20:06:15.000Z
- Description: The 'Star Wars' movie rankings in 2024
- Author: M.G. Siegler
- Tags: star wars, film, entertainment

As we get farther and farther away from the last of the *Star Wars* movies (December will mark **five years** since *The Rise of Skywalker*), it feels like the perspective of how good (or [bad](https://500ish.com/the-phantom-menace-sucked-ba88b284f6dd?ref=spyglass.org)) they are is coming more into focus. So naturally, we must rank the movies, [as David French did](https://www.threads.net/@davidfrenchjag/post/C6jjECHOgfw?ref=spyglass.org). I think [he's close](https://www.threads.net/@mgsiegler/post/C6j7oPRIQ76?ref=spyglass.org). Here's how I would rank them:

1. *The Empire Strikes Back*
2. *Rogue One*
3. *A New Hope*
4. *The Force Awakens*
5. *Return of the Jedi*
6. *The Last Jedi*
7. *Solo*
8. *The Rise of Skywalker*
9. *Revenge of the Sith*
10. *Attack of the Clones*
11. *The Phantom Menace*

Or, if you prefer without the tangential films, here's the Roman Numeral order:

V  
IV  
VII  
VI  
VIII  
IX  
III  
II  
I

I like how it's nearly a perfect ascending and descending ramp in form (and you could certainly make a case to switch VI and VII, which would make it so).[1](#footnote) 

In the main list, I honestly wasn't sure where to put *Solo*. I haven't seen it in years but I recall [it being decidedly 'meh'](https://500ish.com/han-what-5c468c19e684?ref=spyglass.org). Not awful, but just not necessary. The most interesting element was Qi'ra and yes, Darth Maul. So I left it right where French put it, which is just ahead of *Rise of Skywalker* and all the prequels.

While those prequels have been getting more nostalgic love in recent years, they remain pretty awful. Certainly in dialogue, but more so the absolute murdering of your senses (in both sense) with way too much CGI. Ewan McGregor remains great (though *Obi-Wan Kenobi*, the series, [nearly broke him](https://500ish.com/obi-wan-mostly-lost-df89ecf210f7?ref=spyglass.org)) and while they've been trying to rehabilitate Hayden Christensen with *Obi-Wan* and especially *Ahsoka*, he'll never be able to outlive [some of those George Lucas lines](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2tLf1JO5bvE&ref=spyglass.org). 

There's seemingly been a sort of resurgence of respect for *Revenge of the Sith*, the third and final prequel. It is the best of the them, no doubt, but it's still worse than any of the other films. Yes, that includes [the whiplash-inducing](https://500ish.com/the-turbulent-whiplash-inducing-repetitive-landing-of-star-wars-da2e33eae8f0?ref=spyglass.org) *Rise of Skywalker*.[2](#footnote) Which was such a mess because of the strange battle between two filmmakers, J.J. Abrams and Rian Johnson. They clearly – *clearly* – should not have had Abrams come back to close out the trilogy he started. I know he was [sort of forced into it](https://www.vulture.com/2017/09/star-wars-episode-8-colin-trevorrow-firing-explanation.html?ref=spyglass.org), but my god, [there has never been a retconning](https://500ish.com/the-retcon-of-the-jedi-33a8088216a6?ref=spyglass.org) like we got in episodes VIII and IX. 

[It's frustrating](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Star%5FWars:%5FThe%5FRise%5Fof%5FSkywalker?ref=spyglass.org) to think [what could have been](https://www.esquire.com/entertainment/movies/a30882356/full-star-wars-9-original-duel-of-fates-script-colin-trevorrow/?ref=spyglass.org)...

*Rogue One* [was great](https://reviewinhaiku.com/post/154540526785/rogue-one?ref=spyglass.org) [when it landed](https://500ish.com/built-on-hope-49c6fb665752?ref=spyglass.org) (despite quite [a bit of turbulence](https://www.wired.com/2016/12/cantina-talk-24/?ref=spyglass.org) in the making of it) and has only gotten better with age. It remains a good lesson, which no one has yet to duplicate in cinema (though [*Andor* has on the small screen](https://500ish.com/a-sunrise-that-i-know-ill-never-see-f7fdb2552fac?ref=spyglass.org)): just make a good movie that happens to be set in the *Star Wars* universe. 

Help us, [James Mangold](https://www.imdb.com/title/tt27485223/?ref=spyglass.org). You're our only hope.

---

1 This order also would best showcase that while the prequels got better over time, the sequels got *worse*. Meanwhile, the original trilogy was the most balanced, with the second film being the best.   
  
2 Though you almost have to put *Rise of Skywalker* into the bottom three for one of the laziest plot crutches in cinematic history: ["Somehow, Palpatine returned."](https://mgs.blog/somehow-project-necromancer-11ceeee7308a?ref=spyglass.org)